Butler’s Fish & Steak Menu

*18% gratuity will be charged for parties of 8 or more.

Butler’s Famous Buffet

Seafood Buffet

All you can eat!
No crab legs, ladies & gents

$31.99

Crab Legs

All you can eat!
Time to get delicious…

$49.99

Buffet & Crab

All you can eat buffet & crabb!
Can you really handle this?

$56.99

Buffet + 2

All you can eat buffet + 2 clusters
Just enough to hit the spot…

$43.67

Buffet + 4

All you can eat buffet + 4 clusters
I’m feeling crabby tonight!

$54.07

3 Cluster Meal

3 clusters + side & salad
You’ve reached optimal crab

$39.99

Sunday Buffet

Our famous weekend buffet takes a delicious turn for Sunday lunch! Let’s just say we include all the country staples you’d expect so you won’t leave hungry. It’s become a New Albany tradition!

$15.99

Kids’ Buffets

We haven’t forgotten the kiddos! Kids 12 and under can enjoy our buffets at a reduced rate. View kids’ menu here.

Kids Seafood – $9.99
Kids Seafood + 2 Crabb Legs – $34.99
Kids Seafood + AYCE Cr Legs – $43.99
Kids Country Buffet – $7.99

Appetizers

Appetizers

Butler’s Chop Sticks
$8.32

Cheese Sticks
$8.32

Fried Green Tomatoes
$8.32

Fried Mushrooms
$8.32

Fried Pickle Chips
$8.32

Queso Blanco Dip
$6.23 | $9.35 | $13.51

Sides, Salads & Ad Ons

Sides & Salads

All sides $3.11
French Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
Baked Potato
Baked Sweet Potato
Steamed Broccoli & Cheese
Onion Rings
Mac & Cheese
Fried Okra
Corn on the cob

Side Salad
$6.23

Unlimited Salad Bar
$10.39

Add Chicken Grilled/Fried
$4.15

Add Ons
Chicken Strip $2.99
Catfish Filet $3.99
Whole Catfish $5.99
4pc Shrimp (Grilled/Fried) $6.99
Hushpuppies $3.99
Bacon $1.99
Crab Legs Cluster $12.99
14 piece Fried Oysters $14.99

Sandwiches

Sandwiches

Philly Cheesesteak
$13.51

Deluxe Hamburger
$13.51

Shrimp PoBoy
$14.50

Catfish PoBoy
$14.50

Steaks & Chops

Steak & Chops

10oz-12oz New York Strip
$22.87

Ribeye Steak
8 oz. – $22.87
10 oz. – $25.99
12 oz. – $29.11
16 oz. – $35.35

Steak for 2 (8 oz Ribeyes)
$36.39

8oz Filet Mignon
$31.19

12 oz Center Cut Pork Chop
$16.63

Hamburger Steak 10-12oz
$15.59

Country Fried Steak
$15.59

Fish & Shrimp

Fish and Shrimp

Catfish Fillets
2 pc. – $12.47
4 pc. – $15.59
6 pc. – $18.71

1 whole – $12.47
2 whole – $15.59

Salmon
$20.79

Shrimp

6pc Fried/Grilled Shrimp Skewer
$12.47

12pc Fried/Grilled Shrimp Skewer
$15.59

6pc Fried Shrimp
$12.47

12pc Fried Shrimp
$15.59

Chicken

chicken

8oz Grilled Chicken 
(Original/Lemon Pepper/Cajun)
$14.55

Smokehouse Chicken 
$15.59

Chicken Tips 
(Original/Lemon Pepper/Cajun)
$15.59

Hand Battered Chicken Tenders
2 Piece – $11.43
4 Piece – $14.55

Fried Chicken Livers Dinner 
$13.51

Butler’s Kids Menu

Butler's Fish and Steak

All kids’ menu items include a side of fries OR Mac & Cheese. Looking for the buffet? Click here to see kids’ buffet pricing.

Kids’ Menu – $6.00

Kids Fish Fillet (1 strip)

Kids Chicken Strip (1 strip)

Kids Grilled Cheese 

Kids Pizza Stick (1 stick)

Kids Hamburger 

Kids Corndog Nuggets

Desserts

If you are able, we have some amazing desserts in store!

Daily Specials
$4

Chocolate Cobbler
$2

Peach Cobbler
$2

Banana Pudding
$2

Drink Menu

Drink Menu

Drinks – $2.99

Sweet/Unsweet Tea
Dr Pepper
Coke
Mello Yello
Lemonade
Diet Coke
Sprite
Coke Zero
Diet Dr. Pepper
Coffee

Beers / Seltzers – $4

Coors Light
Miller Light
Corona
Dos Equis
Bud Light
Michelob Ultra
Truly
White Claw
Simply Spiked Lemonade

*18% gratuity will be charged for parties of 8 or more.